
Yes, this news is old. I was in London this past week, thereby unable and/or unwilling to post on this news item, let alone anything else of note. Even though this blog focuses on Miami, when your #1 rival’s only head coach ever is forced out, it’s opinion worthy.
Now, all those claiming Bowden was not forced out, that this was a true retirement, please spare me your breath. This guy would have “coached” until he died on the sideline.
“I was kind of hoping to get another year,” Bowden said to begin the show. “It was going to be either this year or next year. That was as far as I was going to go.”
If you grew up on the unstoppable Noles teams of the 90s, as I did, and truly loathed them for this fact, you can name their starting QBs in succession in a matter of seconds. Charlie Ward begat Danny Kanell, who begat Thad Busby, who begat Chris Weinke. Florida State pretty much created the “QB stud doesn’t play until his Junior year” rule, and then was awesome for two seasons. Michigan did the same thing for the majority of the 90s, and both them and FSU proved the practice as a successful one. Michigan had Elvis Grbac, Todd Collins, Brian Greise, Tom Brady, Drew Henson. What killed both Florida State’s and Michigan’s run of greatness? The first year both teams didn’t have upperclassmen starting QBs. For Michigan it was when Henson stupidly decided to leave football his junior season for the Yankees. For Florida State, it was when Chris Rix was given the job as a true freshman, never to relinquish it as he was always just good enough and thereby always had more experience than his competition to beat him out. You get a QB who starts as a true frosh, and you end up scaring away other great QBs, with transfers and late recruiting switches.
Before I get into any of the problems Bowden has created in the past 10 years, let me first recognize what he did. Lest we all forget, his Seminole teams were disgustingly brilliant. They destroyed the ACC so effortlessly, the conference has still not recovered in the national media. Even I still consider the ACC a lesser conference, namely because I remember that no team, literally, could ever beat Florida State, and that was embarrassing. But really, perhaps Florida State was just that good. Bowden also beat up on Steve Spurrier, back when he put a whooping on the entire SEC. The last 10 years notwithstanding, Bobby Bowden was an incredible coach, and did a fantastic job of managing the egos of his many assistant coaches and the personalities of the poor black youth that made his teams near unstoppable.
The most notable stat from Bowden’s tenure is his 14 consecutive year run of finishing in the top five of the rankings. 1987-2000, his teams never dropped below #5. Unreal. However, when you have the opinion I did (and still do) of the ’90s ACC teams, you took that streak with a grain of shit. As in, Florida State got to beat eight shit teams each year to pad their record, playing only Miami and Florida each year to drop a potential game. No, the stat I think best shows Bobby Bowden’s excellence is the following: during his 14 year run, his record in bowl games was 11-3, with all three losses in national title games. And lets not act subjective here. If Weinke is not hurt in the ‘98 title game, FSU destroys Tennessee. Anyways, regardless of how the breaks fell, that bowl record is uncanny. It completely refutes the padding of the record in the ACC. Florida State would obliterate their new conference opponents, and then do the same against the best competition of the nation on neutral sites. Bowden’s overall bowl record, counting the past 10 years of ineptitude, is still near untouchable at 20-9-1.
Knowing and experiencing all of this, I always figured that once Bowden had gotten too old to at least throw his hand in their once in awhile, his program started to die. Meaning, right around the time Chris Rix showed up. Not so, I was told. Seems a friend of mine who works in South Florida television got the scoop. From whom you ask? Well, none other than Danny Kanell. That’s right, the QB from 1994-95. He said even back when he played, Bowden didn’t do shit. A surprise definitely, but not a shock. Mark Richt should be backdated all those wins from 1994-2000. It is obvious now, but it took until about 2005 until the entire nation realized that Richt leaving for Georgia was the catalyst for Florida State’s demise. I’ve stated this before about Miami’s defense, but I will again. Defensive coaching in college football is overrated, at least when compared to the offense. To be great on defense in college, you just need the best players. Simple as that. Florida State, for the entire ’90s, had the best players. Mickey Andrews didn’t slow down, he just stopped getting the best players.
What does all this mean for the future of Florida State football? Not much, for now. Jimbo Fisher will completely clean house, as he should. Right now, if I was an FSU fan, I’d be arguing to get rid of Fisher, open the job to the market. Fisher was once the nation’s darling of offensive coordinators, but he hasn’t exact lit the Doak on fire these past three years. Sure, he has been better than Jeff Bowden, but that is like saying I feel better this week than last, when I had diarrhea coming out of my ears.
This is not to say Jimbo Fisher cannot turn things around in Tallahassee. None of us truly know his capabilities, because he was handcuffed his entire time there. Mickey Andrews, Chuck Amato, and Bobby Bowden were all throwing their chef hat into the kitchen. Once Fisher rids himself of all the outside forces imposing on his program, there’s no telling the ceiling.
The only question is if there is enough players in Florida to fill three top 10 programs. I’ve always argued that any talent rich state, such as Texas, California, or Florida, can only sustain enough top flight talent for two schools to compete for national titles. Once Texas and Oklahoma became great again, Texas A&M went by the wayside almost immediately. Never has all three Sunshine State schools been national title contenders at the same time. In the ’80s Florida sucked, in the ’90s Miami sucked, in the ’00s FSU and Miami have been bad. Think of any year one of the three teams even just played in the national title game, and there was only one other of the three who were good that year. Never fails. This means that Jimbo Fisher needs to either recruit his ass off to start stealing these players from the Gators and Canes, or perhaps build a pipeline to nearby states like Louisiana and Alabama. Of course, Nick Saban owns those states, so it’s not like he can just put his flag down and claim it, Boomer Sooner style. As a Hurricane fan, I would be much more worried if Jimbo Fisher was given full reigns back in 2007 when his stock was at it’s peak. Now, three years into his tenure as OC, Fisher has to show me he is capable of out recruiting Randy Shannon and Urban Meyer. I’m not sure that he can.
Ultimately, Bobby Bowden would have been better served to feign an illness back after the 2000 title game loss to Oklahoma. Sure, Paterno would have easily won the overall wins battle, but history would remember Bowden didn’t have to coach another decade to pad his stats like JoePa has. There is a reason Bowden has a statue outside Doak Campell Stadium. He built a program at a women’s school, in a city and area of Florida no one wants to live. However, knowing now this past decade of turmoil, and the seemingly clear Mark Richt’s advantage of the entire 1990s, Bowden will now be remembered as the coach who stayed too long, and refused to give in to outsiders making any claims against himself or his family.