
I don't like abortions because they might turn out to be great mediocre QBs who I make awesome and build my reputation on! Pro-choice! Pro-choice!
Per my usual scheduling conflicts, I am late the ball on many major college football news items. Not that is hurts my opinions; in fact, it lets them sink in longer, and eradicates the knee-jerk reactions that many subpar bloggers succeed with in being mediocre.
I did a quick search of my site’s beginnings, and found this Nostradamus gem of a post–Brian Kelly to stay at Cincinnati, and who cares because Notre Dame will be open next year! I’ll admit, predicting Charlie “FUPA” Weis being fired one year prior to his dismissal is not of the Mayan 2012 variety. Yet, I will still add it to the factors in my claim I know more college football than you. I had another previous post on Brian Kelly to Notre Dame last December, prior to this site going all Canes, all the time. No doubt nobody read that, so if you want, check it out. I’ll borrow one bit from that post, of my favorite all time NFL player, for selfish reasons.

Because no one saw it last year
Now let me address the situation at hand–Brian Kelly finally being hired at Notre Dame. A friend of mine always debates Notre Dame is past its prime. They are done, never to be good again. His opinion has merit, at least in an objective sense. Being a Syracuse alum, he says “I have no reason to be subjective or bias. My team sucks anyways.” Valid point.
While I agree with his point, that Notre Dame is not what it used to be, I still feel the right coach can turn the program back into a national powerhouse. Not the pseudo variety Charlie Weis and Bob Davie accomplished, unjustly qualifying for BCS bowl games only to be embarrassed with everything except their television market share. Recently I read that, sans Tyrone Willingham, every time Notre Dame has hired a coach with previous collegiate coaching success, they have won a national title with said coach. That’s rather remarkable when you think about it. Funny that Notre Dame has been unable to hire a coach for the past 15 years with any sort of college success, but the main point is remarkable as well.
Brian Kelly finally confirming the predicted inevitable of being hired will let the entire country know if my said Orange alum friend is correct. If Urban Meyer stupidly went to South Bend instead of Gainesville five year ago, we would already know. Does Meyer win two national titles already? Of course not. At the same time, I think he still wins one before he would have left, assuming he stuck around for a decade or more.
Meyer is like most college coaches, football or basketball. Stock pile your roster with the best, fastest, most agile players in the country, don’t fuck it up, and win lots of games. Mack Brown and Roy Williams will have stadiums named after themselves by sticking to this exact career path. Randy Shannon is following this strategy, and I couldn’t be happier. For all intents and purposes, you don’t want that coach who is an actual coaching genius. What happens when he leaves? Do you think Cincinnati actually has great players, or the ability for the new coach to now recruit them? They will go back to being the Big East’s whipping boys, able to spring maybe one conference upset a year. Therein lies the Brian Kelly factor.
Brian Kelly has never had good players since coming to D1. Yes, at D2 Grand Valley State he had the best players in the country. Why? Because he spent a decade there building the program, and by the time he left, every fringe D1 prospect who wanted guaranteed playing time, and every Midwestern player who was unhappy where he was at transferred to play for Kelly. He took that talent and won two straight D2 titles, with a title game loss the year prior. Since then, Kelly has only coached subpar talent. Central Michigan does not need to be discussed, as we now what the MAC produces on a yearly basis. Cincinnati? Go ask any NFL scout how many players from that team, today, will ever make it to a starting position in the NFL. I doubt he can give you half a handful. Tony Pike is not an NFL prospect. All those claiming he was a hidden gem, please, stop. College recruiters are not complete idiots, as most are wont to say. They know talent. Pike was blessed to be given the greatest offensive play caller in the past decade, and a good head coach to boot (unlike FUPA Weis).
This is the crux of my argument in believing Brian Kelly will finally “Return to Glory®” (since 1993) the once proud Notre Dame program. Kelly has never experienced the type of talent he will get just by showing up at a kid’s house with the ND emblem on his chest. If he can take a bunch of second tier miscreants from a commuter school, in a state owned by a traditional powerhouse, just think what he can do with South Bend’s allure on his side. This is not to say Kelly will start pumping out one national title win after another. The best players per capita will always reside in the South and Southwest, which means the Florida’s and Texas’ of the world will never have less talent. I believe Notre Dame’s ceiling, until proven otherwise, is to consistently qualify for BCS games, and actually play USC in a toss up of who will win. They perhaps can win one national title in a ten year window; the clouds always part for the well-coached independent school. Look at USC–if they played the top two teams of every conference, outside the Pac 10, they probably go undefeated every year and win by two touchdowns. Instead, they play teams that are used to their style, know how to beat them, pick off coaches from Carroll’s staff and use their knowledge to their advantage. Crappy conference teams have a way of beating the juggernauts.
Assuming Notre Dame becomes great again, it will cause the media to do their normal overhyping of the program. More importantly, for fans of teams like USC, Texas, and hopefully soon Miami, it will under-hype the opponents. I’d love nothing more than for Miami and Notre Dame to meet in the BCS title game, preferably the Orange Bowl, and have the entire nation wondering how any team, let alone one coached by Randy Shannon, could beat the unstoppable genius of Brian Kelly. By 30. In the sweaty rain. While taunting the 70% Irish crowd and causing them to hallucinate their 1980s memories to the forefront of their conservative brains.
If Kelly does indeed accomplish what many think he can, not implausible given his track record, Urban Meyer will rue the day he twice turned down Notre Dame. Yes, I said twice. Officially in 2004, and we all know his agent was contacted and told to tell Meyer the job is his if he wants it, and money is no object. He turned it down. Now imagine this: Brian Kelly rights this ship, competes for national titles, and even if he never wins one, an .800+ winning percentage over 10+ years will cause for erecting a statue in his honor. Urban Meyer can win another five titles in Gainesville, and he will always be kept warm at night. He doesn’t even use a blanket. Steve Spurrier’s shadow is all the warmth that he needs.